Difference in Speedtest and Billion down rate - why?
Posted: Tue Feb 10, 2015 9:34 am
Sorry this is long. I have struggled for a month with my internet. Let me begin by saying I am not very technical. We live quite rurally, not far from the exchange as the crow flies, but quite a ways by road.
Early January, BT replaced a pole near us. We lost the internet. They fixed it, saying the workers had not reconnected the line. Internet came back but where I had been seeing 4.6-4.9mb down, I was now getting 2.1 and even down to .8, with the SNR creeping up daily.
1st engineer - brilliant. Spent 5 hours here. tested the line, no errors, called my ISP (Spitfire) to no an SNR reset and once he convinced them he wasn't trying to mimic an improvement by just resetting the SNR and claiming it had fixed the slow speed, he retested. 203 errors in 217 seconds. Spent the next 3 ours driving to and fro and testing to try to isolate the problem. Submitted the job to have a length of cable replaced.
ISP called BT who claimed they had replaced the cable. The time they gave was the time the engineer was standing outside my window, directly in from of the security camera, holding up the yellow ticket in on hand and a hammer to nail it to the pole in the other. Oops.
2nd Engineer - nice but useless. Appointment time between 8 and 1. Arrived at abut 12:50 to tell me that no, the cable had not been replaced sorry. But the job had been resubmitted.
3rd engineer - pointless. ISP said they had to book another engineer to "move the job along" and I should call them when he arrived. 8-1 appt, arrived 12:20. I called ISP and they basically told him there was nothing for him to do, just not close the job.
BT said they had to get permission from the council to dig.
Finally they assigned a day. claimed the cable had been replaced, but my speed was still in the 2 range and and there is absolutely no evidence of any digging (at least not along the road between here and the pole the engineer defined as the problem area, and not in the field between us and the road. I know that is not concrete evidence but still...)
Bought the Billion 7800DXL because of the SNR tweaks. The engineer said the line should get, by his testing, 5mb. At the pole it tested 8mb but that is a pipe dream
Installed. SNR showed at 16.5
Did the tweak 4093 to lower it 9 dB
Here is where it gets weird.
My Billion shows SNR of 4.9
Rate (Kbps) 6016 down 704 up
the online speedtest (Ookla) shows 28ms ping 3.32 down .58 up
the online non-flash SpeedofMe test shows 27ms ping 3.66 down 700 up
It seems sluggish. not anything like 6mb
Will asking my ISP to reset the SNR and then setting it to the standard -1 help? Which speedtest do I believe? Why would my router lie to me?
Previously I had a Draytek 2800VG. That also showed a difference between the online speedtest and the router speeds but it was usually less than .5 mb, never as much as 2!
Thanks for any info or guidance.
Any helpful info?
Cheers
Mary Anne
Early January, BT replaced a pole near us. We lost the internet. They fixed it, saying the workers had not reconnected the line. Internet came back but where I had been seeing 4.6-4.9mb down, I was now getting 2.1 and even down to .8, with the SNR creeping up daily.
1st engineer - brilliant. Spent 5 hours here. tested the line, no errors, called my ISP (Spitfire) to no an SNR reset and once he convinced them he wasn't trying to mimic an improvement by just resetting the SNR and claiming it had fixed the slow speed, he retested. 203 errors in 217 seconds. Spent the next 3 ours driving to and fro and testing to try to isolate the problem. Submitted the job to have a length of cable replaced.
ISP called BT who claimed they had replaced the cable. The time they gave was the time the engineer was standing outside my window, directly in from of the security camera, holding up the yellow ticket in on hand and a hammer to nail it to the pole in the other. Oops.
2nd Engineer - nice but useless. Appointment time between 8 and 1. Arrived at abut 12:50 to tell me that no, the cable had not been replaced sorry. But the job had been resubmitted.
3rd engineer - pointless. ISP said they had to book another engineer to "move the job along" and I should call them when he arrived. 8-1 appt, arrived 12:20. I called ISP and they basically told him there was nothing for him to do, just not close the job.
BT said they had to get permission from the council to dig.
Finally they assigned a day. claimed the cable had been replaced, but my speed was still in the 2 range and and there is absolutely no evidence of any digging (at least not along the road between here and the pole the engineer defined as the problem area, and not in the field between us and the road. I know that is not concrete evidence but still...)
Bought the Billion 7800DXL because of the SNR tweaks. The engineer said the line should get, by his testing, 5mb. At the pole it tested 8mb but that is a pipe dream

Installed. SNR showed at 16.5
Did the tweak 4093 to lower it 9 dB
Here is where it gets weird.
My Billion shows SNR of 4.9
Rate (Kbps) 6016 down 704 up
the online speedtest (Ookla) shows 28ms ping 3.32 down .58 up
the online non-flash SpeedofMe test shows 27ms ping 3.66 down 700 up
It seems sluggish. not anything like 6mb
Will asking my ISP to reset the SNR and then setting it to the standard -1 help? Which speedtest do I believe? Why would my router lie to me?

Previously I had a Draytek 2800VG. That also showed a difference between the online speedtest and the router speeds but it was usually less than .5 mb, never as much as 2!
Thanks for any info or guidance.
Any helpful info?
Cheers
Mary Anne